I’m tired of political wrangling, ‘dithering’ as Peggy Noonan puts it in her recent editorial in the Wall St. Journal. She begins by assailing, or perhaps it’s better to say ‘accurately describing,’ typical Washington politicians. But then she turns to the politics of the Supreme Court, and makes some penetrating points:
The Supreme Court this week and last issued many rulings, and though they were on different issues the decisions themselves had at least one thing in common: They seemed to reflect a lack of basic human modesty on the part of many of the justices. Many are famously very old, and they have been together as a court for a very long time. One wonders if they have lost all understanding of how privileged they are to have lifetime sinecures of power and authority. Do they have any sense anymore of common human wisdom, of the normal human arrangements by which Americans live?
Maybe a lot of them aren’t bothering to think. Maybe Ruth Bader Ginsburg is no longer in the habit of listening to arguments but only of watching William Rehnquist, and if he nods up and down she knows to vote "no," and if he shakes his head she knows to vote "yes." That might explain some of the lack of seriousness in the decisions. Local government can bulldoze Grandma’s house because it’s in the way of a future strip mall that will add more to the tax base? The Ten Commandments can appear on public land but not in a courthouse, but Moses, who received the Ten Commandments can appear in the frieze of the House but he’ll be sandblasted off the Supreme Court? Or do I have that the other way around?
What are they doing? All this hair splitting, this dithering, this cutting and pasting–all this lack of serious and defining principle. All this vanity.
Yes, it is vanity and it is quite depressing. I’m going to celebrate the July 4th holiday by pretending that this country is run by people who don’t seek the limelight, by people who work hard to do what’s right even when it is against their own self-interest.
I know that makes no sense, and I know I’m naive. I plan to stay that way as long as I can.
P.S. If you're a practicing lawyer, check out this Law Practice Assessment . After answering a few questions, you'll get detailed recommendations for improving five key areas of your practice.
